Social care is the responsibility of councils in Wales, Scotland, and England.
Between an ageing population, a health service that’s been strained to the very limits, and a simple lack of funding, the ease of accessing social care in the UK and Wales has rarely looked worse.
In a study put together by the Shared Data Unit and BBC Wales on the ongoing issues facing social and domiciliary care. Since the publishing of the Dilnot report twelve years ago, and the recommendations it suggested to put an end to the “postcode lottery” style of social care provision, little positive progress has been made.
While there have been various attempts at reform, some of the most notable being 2014 Care Act, as well as the 2022 Health and Care Act, social care campaign groups have criticised what they see as an underfunding and understaffing of the system, which has never been appropriately addressed.
The criticism has reasonable basis in fact and reality, with the number of people who died while waiting to receive support in the form of a care package in Wales reaching 138 people between 2022 and 2023.
This comes at the same time as the Care Support Alliance, a group representing over 60 charities in England, has placed renewed pressure on Rishi Sunak to honour the UK Government’s 2019 promise to solve the ongoing issue with social care provision, with the group describing it as like having “been on a wild goose chase” as policy after policy has been quietly forgotten by the government.
However, last year the crisis facing the industry was acknowledged by the House of Commons Health and Social Care Committee, stating that there would need to be the introduction of an additional 490,000 more employees into the care system by the latter part of the 2030s to stand any chance of addressing the problem.
The government previously set out a 10 year plan for major care reform, at the time pledging £1.7 billion of improvement. However, those plans were scaled back in April of this year, with £600m of the promised figure being held back until after the next general election in 2025 in a move considered deeply cynical by many.
Presently, more than 13,000 home-care packages have been handed back to councils by the companies administering them over the past two years, largely because of staffing issues leading these companies to be unable to fulfil their side of the contract.
This is a problem that has been exacerbated by the additional complications around sourcing migrant labour since the implementation of Brexit.
To receive care package funding, individuals are assessed by their council for eligibility. If considered eligible, a placement is found to meet their needs. This will be partly or fully funded by the council, depending on the individual’s needs and circumstances. People can either refer theirself or be referred for assessment by a clinician.
Waiting times for initial assessments to receive care support were found to take over a month for a third of the UK, though often much worse in some places; in the Vale of Glamorgan, the average waiting time for an initial assessment was found to be over 100 days, with it taking, on average, up to a further 10 weeks after that to start receiving care. Some were found to be waiting up to 156 days.
In Carmarthenshire, the picture painted is less grim, though still a concern to anyone who could potentially be affected; while the average wait for an initial assessment was only 3 days, the longest amount of time an individual had to wait for their initial assessment was 300 days over the 2022 to 2023 period. However, this was a significant improvement to the last financial year prior to that, where the average waiting time was 43 days, and the longest individual waiting time was 414 days. Unfortunately, during the last financial year 28 people have died in Carmarthenshire waiting for the start of their care package. We approached Carmarthenshire County Council for comment, but they did not respond at time of publication.
Caroline Abrahams, charity director at Age UK, said:
“It’s valuable to see all this data pulled together and it tells a pretty consistent story: that of a care system struggling to meet growing levels of need overall, but one which is doing better in some parts of the country compared to others. The extent of the postcode lottery the data reveals is unacceptably large, because it means your chances of getting a timely care assessment, for example, vary enormously according to where you live, and that’s just not fair on all those losing out, some of whom are sadly dying before ever receiving the help they need.”
While the picture has seen some improvement at the local level here in Carmarthenshire, the need for improvement is considered a necessity by many, which some consider to be an uncertain prospect with the current UK government’s approach to addressing this industry wide problem. For better or worse, time will tell.















